There’s hollow marketing campaigns to build hype and then there’s this. Poe having a love interest is cute but it really could have been cut a lot heavier. It would have been unforgettable, and would have given the film real stakes. I can’t stress this part enough. Rey has a moment where she sees all of this. The dark side of Rey actually being a plot point. "TROS" closes out the final film in the George Lucas Skywalker saga which followed young Anakin Skywalker's descent … —The Mary Sue has a strict comment policy that forbids, but is not limited to, personal insults toward anyone, hate speech, and trolling.—, Have a tip we should know? Thankfully, then, our sources have now shed a bit more light on what fans can expect from Mark Hamill’s hero going into The Rise of Skywalker. Walt Disney Studios. Want more stories like this? Maybe consider buying your old pal ElderlyGoose a Kofi?Just click the link here https://ko-fi.com/A0A18JTG and for £3 consider yourself sorted for one good deed done for the day! Don't Come For the Internet's Boyfriend: Nick Miller Edition, Things We Saw Today: Keira Knightley Explains Why She’s Done Filming Sex Scenes Directed by Men, Things We Saw Today: We Get a First Look at Amazon’s, Things We Saw Today: Batman Superfan Now President Pro Tempore of the Senate, Things We Saw Today: Biden Inauguration Fashion Sparked Monochromatic Appreciation and Many Memes, More than 66,000 marijuana convictions will be dismissed in Los Angeles County, as well they should be. It’s hard not to feel like this parody just absolutely eviscerated the plotting behind a massive blockbuster. “Chosen one!” But honestly? While a thrilling joyride in its pacing and scope, the film is dragged back down to earth with the introduction of a major revelation: … What's Going on With Kellyanne and Claudia Conway? Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Yes it has a huge market but this was tone deaf and reeked of cash in. Rose now a Jedi Master begins teaching, Ray still goes to bury Luke and Leia, Poe and Finn start the work to setup yet another New Republic. A misery? Email us. Rogue One proved you could do a spin off even if CGI tried to ruin it. If The Rise Of Skywalker had been two movies, we could have spent one discovering the return of Palpatine, and gone into more depth about the rise of … Obviously I’m not saying, “I could do a better job” here. You’re not alone, Mace. The Last Jedi had some of the best cinematography of all time. Or to keep it anonymous, click here. The change in the dynamic between the main cast unchanged. All of a sudden the New Republic was gone, the next thing the galaxy knew the resistance was nearly wiped out and then the Emperor lives? Happy president’s day to Americans who like presidents! Did you enjoy the fact there were no adverts for your adblocker to deal with? Director J.J. Abrams and Oscar Isaac are seen on the set of "The Rise of Skywalker." What did you see today? Instead of simply being a shadow jump scare the dark side of Rey is shown throughout. ( Log Out /  “Yes!” Anakin says, throwing his hands into the air after throwing Palpatine off a steep ledge (again). “That feel out of nowhere to anyone else?” asks Mace Windu as Rey and Kylo Ren make out. How The Rise of Skywalker should have been a force for amazing cinema It has been a year since The Rise of Skywalker and finally the dust has settled. Kaila is a lifelong New Yorker. Case in point: The latest entry in the franchise and purported final chapter of the Skywalker Saga, The Rise of Skywalker.Reactions to this final Star Wars epic have been decidedly mixed. Founder of Multiplayer and Press Thing For Podcast. tips@themarysue.com. Disney may have made a corporate grab to try to ensure positive fan reaction as much as possible, but we don’t know that and probably never will. It really didn’t need to up the scale of the fleet to insane levels, a decent sized fleet of the existing ships would be enough to warrant fear from the galaxy, “a return of the control of the past” Having Lando pop back with more than a WOO would also save the weight of trying to dial up the impending doom and the outside attack being more of a bump to Rey than anything else. Think of how much more interesting The Rise of Skywalker would have been without Palpatine, if it had been a story about the battle for Kylo Ren’s soul instead of a … If we can have a man with no lower half still come back with robot legs and powers than this is no less bizarre. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Why in gods name would your serious Sci-fi epic need a dramatic reveal to occur in Fortnite of all things? Have a tip or story idea? Imagine if the array of Jedi voices she heard in her head really materialized into the beloved characters many of us were hoping to see, and they helped with their amazing combined Jedi powers! ↩ Anyone hoping for friendship between Rey and Rose in this movie will be sorely disappointed. The Rise of Skywalker shows every sign of having been repeatedly dismembered and put together again in the editing room, like a patchwork Frankenstein of a movie. Now do this on a federal level. These nine films may have been dubbed the "Skywalker Saga," but thanks to the sequel trilogy, we know that the Skywalker … Ray and Poe arguing over the Falcon like a married couple with Finn stepping in to keep the peace. Maybe instead of him simply tagging along with Poe and Rey having Finn stop an ambush in the market scene because he knows the First Order protocols and procedures already. This was the sort of moment I was hoping we might get to see in Rise of Skywalker. It would have been a huge fight, the massive showpiece of the film that if it wasn’t trying to cram so much in would have been a fantastic closer instead of another pause in Act 2. ‘DC’s Stargirl’ Did What ‘Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker’ Should Have Done. Han Solo got the spotlight in The Force Awakens, and Luke Skywalker's story dominated The Last Jedi.With The Rise of Skywalker… After the sad passing of Leia and Carrie the shift to them both trying to master their abilities would play in nicely into Rey dealing with her affinity for the dark side, always blaming Rose for being too young to teach anything. The shadow Rey in the room could be the breaking point, instead of being a simple one use shot have that version continue to show up from that point. With only the ghosts of the Sith and Palpatine to defeat it’s at this point that she can spirit bomb him with the force to save the day. You’re not alone. He goes ZWWWMM she goes ZWWWM we have a samurai fight moment. Nothing particularly new for the franchise but I thought they might have learnt from The Star Wars Holiday Special. It has been a year since The Rise of Skywalker and finally the dust has settled. Have her being more snappy with people, conflicted on mastering the force with wanting to progress and deal with the first order more quickly. Don’t Come For the Internet’s Boyfriend: Nick Miller Edition, Tiktok’s ‘Your Korean Dad’ Is the Wholesome Content I Need Today. Pushing her psyche further, warning her of the dark side. Rise of Skywalker may have been damned from the outset. Atelier Arland series: Deluxe Pack – Switch, Atelier Meruru – The Apprentice of Arland DX – Switch. He falls. Have them putting pressure on Kylo throughout. Now equipped with two sabres she goes to Palpatine and runs into what’s left of the Knights of Ren, loses but only just and is brought before Palpatine who murders the Knight before her and shows her that she’s not that dark after all. There could have been the reluctant return, the past character on their track, the fantastic scene with C3PO where a surprisingly emotional moment occurs and then a quick escape. Get 70% off NordVPN! Imagine if Finn just shot Kylo Ren on sight with a blaster! We’ve all had the time to process and time to chat about it. Actually have them fight Rey throughout and not Kylo (maybe have one of them pilot the Tie fighter in that amazing scene) There’s enough of them to easy have one of them killed and still be a threat. It wouldn’t need to be much, a comment here or there but it would make his interactions with ex-troopers later on have more meaning. We see the history of the Sith through her eyes, the murders, the plots, the dark side of the force and cameos from the past. There has always been chemistry between the three, even with the introduction of Rose the trio fit so well together and there feels like this might have been a plan early on in production. Change ). Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. These are just ideas that I’d love to discuss, hell talking Star Wars is fantastic (when it’s not with trolls) and let’s just get right on into it. ( Log Out /  Linda Maleh Former Contributor. Things We Saw Today: “How It Should Have Ended” for The Rise of Skywalker Is Better Than The Rise of Skywalker By Kaila Hale-Stern Feb 17th, 2020, 6:00 pm screengrab/How It Should Have Ended What’s Going on With Kellyanne and Claudia Conway? The sequel trilogy has divided Star Wars fans like never before, with some arguing that the whole thing was a mistake, while others generally enjoying the experience. I absolutely love The Force Awakens, it’s my favourite Star Wars movie. Rise was supposed to have been directed by Colin Trevorrow, who as far as I know has yet to establish an identity as a director, and who is still credited on the film's story. The response to both the Emperor’s return and the execution of that return in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker has been quite mixed. Less need for awkward kisses by space nazis. December 20, 2019. In contrast, in Dark Empire Luke Skywalker really does fall to the dark side, and the emotional focus of the film is upon the redemptive love of Luke's sister. The popular YouTube channel How It Should Have Ended has finally shared its take on Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, and it pokes fun at several perceived plot holes while offering a compelling alternate climactic sequence. Jonathan Olley/Lucasfilm "The Force Awakens" director J.J. Abrams returns to bring the new trilogy to a close after Colin Trevorrow ("Jurassic World") parted ways with Lucasfilm as director. It's been over a year since Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker arrived in theaters, and it remains as divisive as ever. (via. Especially when they get un-ceremonially killed off in the final act. And of course, it wouldn’t be a How It Should Have Ended without a gathering of villains. I saw The Rise of Skywalker both the day before it released and on opening day, and like many fans, it felt like a moment I’d been waiting for my entire life. The Knights of Ren actually having a part to play. It could, just not with Rey as the leading role. ... and is not lamenting over a fairytale of who her father could have been. The Rise of Skywalker is a fine popcorn movie, splashy and forgettable like recent Transformers and Terminators films. ( Log Out /  I don’t run a Patreon because all the work I create ends up on the site in one way or another and I fund the site myself so any money does directly go to the site to fund the web hosting and such, anything left over will go on games and coffee! We’ve all had the time to process and time to chat about it. Ted Cruz Compares Journalists to the Borg, Clearly Doesn’t Understand, Brie Larson Is Coming to Terms With Being Pietro in. The moments of interaction between Luke, Anakin, and Ben Solo in cartoon form made me feel emotions. There are still a few good moments to be had in The Rise of Skywalker but I bet you don’t remember the informant, Richard E. Grant doing his best General performance or some funny bonkers lines because it’s just too bogged down in it’s own ridiculousness. More of an emphasis of the “I am one with the Force. When it comes to Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, there are a lot of changes that should have been made to give us a more satisfying finale for the Skywalker saga. You’d be investing in a space bunker to. Yes I am the Lord of Things. Imagine if Rey used her Force powers to save her friends from sinking into sand! The prequels were pod racing, duel of fates and “hello there”. The theme throughout is less about a galaxy in fear of the First Order and more the lack of communication throughout. The Star Wars sequel trilogy has long lacked a consistent vision, and it paid the price in the end. Become a subscriber and support the site! Various versions of scenes were cut, then recut. Scott Mendelson for Forbes described the film as "possibly worse than any prior Star Wars 'episode'. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Even Zorii gets to rule the underworld as an extra scene. This feels like it should have been split into two movies. “Yeah, I don’t know what to think about it,” says Obi-Wan Kenobi. The assault on Palpatine is more about Rey fighting herself, The shadows, the knights, seeing herself as the new Kylo now she’s murdered him, seeing herself as the Queen of the Empire. By the end of the film we end up with a lot of awkward pairings and this would have fixed a lot of those problems. The Rise of Skywalker was released roughly a year ago. Abrams, Terrio, and everyone should have taken an extra year Finn shouldn’t have just been a character for people to dump their problems on throughout the film and yell, “WOO” He was a stormtrooper before the events in this film, it would have been nice to see him at least dealing a little with that. Resurrection is a weird little motif in The Rise of Skywalker, and maybe I should have expected that given the title. What better way to include a big role for Kelly Marie Tran and throw a curve ball to the story? 2. The Rise of Skywalker trailers have made us believe we're going to see a number of things that probably won't actually happen -- here's a look at some of the biggest misdirects. It turns out that throughout the Last Jedi she was being taught by Leia and one of the reasons she had the pendant was tied to some Jedi lore. The Rise of Skywalker has been lovingly crafted by a host of talented people, and yet the best they can do is pay tribute to everything he did several decades ago." Why ‘The Rise of Skywalker’ should have killed more characters The filmmakers seemed scared to kill off any fan-favorite heroes. The Rise of Skywalker could have been so much better. Kylo couldn’t be redeemed, Rey wrestling with the Palpatine question doesn’t brutally or intentionally kill Kylo but it happens anyway. “Palpatine got busy?” says Ahsoka incredulously. These gutless storytelling choices are all over The Rise of Skywalker. Dec 20, 2019, 1:28 pm* Though its errors and missed opportunities are many, and it is clear how the journey could have been improved, the “Rise of Skywalker” should still be applauded for what it manages to achieve. Imagine Rey bringing Force Ghost Luke along with her to fight the Emperor! Despite a significant gap of time between VIII and IX, The Rise of Skywalker should pick up where the previous film left off. If you just show people in the background “being menacing” they will eventually lose all potency. What if we mocked all of the weird deus ex machina Force powers that suddenly appeared in the last half of this thing! Stuff writer, podcast maker, games player, manga reader, music listener; person. An uneasy tension pushing him to search for the Emperor not as a solo mission but as a way to keep his royal guard equivalent in line. A comedy recap of Star Wars The Rise of Skywalker with the voices of HISHE. She realises and then takes his sabre and runs. Two movies would have been controversial, but very possibly, more honest to the story Rise of Skywalker was trying to tell. (via, The 100 best movies on Netflix right this very moment. Zorii Bliss could have easily shown up just as they were leaving and allowed him to go still with Poe’s cheeky quip asking for a kiss intact. This is even a good deal more in-character than much of what we saw in TRoS. Despite an 86% Rotten Tomatoes audience score, it appears that J.J. Abrams’ Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker has had a mixed reaction among fans, going by fan comments online. Poe’s past isn’t necessary but the C3PO hacking is. What’s the plural for a collection of villains? Not having a key plot point revealed in Fortnite before the film launched. Almost a year has passed since the release of Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, and the fanbase is still at odds regarding the film's closing moments. A Dark Empire Plot Would Have Improved Rise Of Skywalker In Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker , Dark Rey is a fascinating concept used all too briefly in a narrative that just doesn't quite work. The Rise of Skywalker should've been Leia's movie. Not wanting people to know he was a spice trader and scoundrel fits but the character from his past felt token. Solo had a great train heist and moments throughout. The Rise of Skywalker is proving to be almost -- or maybe equally -- as divisive among critics as The Last Jedi is amongst the Star Wars fandom. I cannot underline this point enough. The folks over at How It Should Have Ended make some of our favorite movie-parody content, but they’ve really gone above and beyond the call of duty with their take on Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. December 20, 2019. Not only does this video hilariously lampoon some of the movie’s biggest plot holes and head-scratching moments, but it also fixes many of them. (And the fact that the first words on … Really though, the premise of the movie, the way it told its story, and the story itself, had nothing to do with any of the words found in The Rise of Skywalker’s title, but that’s not to say the title couldn’t have been the foundation for a very good story. The original trilogy are still the best thing about the franchise but not as stand out as you remember. The death of … Did you like what you read? ( Log Out /  Assassin’s Creed Syndicate – Does it still hold up? WARNING: The following article contains major spoilers for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, in theaters now. Anyway, What do you think? Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker should have been steamier. Make sure to stick around for this video’s “after-credits scene,” which is most definitely a movie that I want to watch. Rose Tico steps in for Princess Leia to teach Ray the Force. Starting out, it had received the mother of all hospital passes from Johnson.The Last Jedi sabotaged many of … I realise polyamory is a bizarre notion to a lot of people but Star Wars is set in the distant future right? The call to arms is the one thing The Rise Of Skywalker got right. Rise of Skywalker comes across as the true sequel to The Force Awakens, virtually rendering The Last Jedi even more disposable than it already was, but by virtue of being the de facto final chapter it feels both rushed and yet overlong for trying to stuff too much into one film. This was already shown when she gets frustrated during training but instead of simply showing this once add in more moments. The Force is with me” than “thank god for my high midichlorian count”, The galaxy still comes to save the day but a little sooner. And here we also have those beloved Force Ghost characters providing the commentary we were all thinking. She's written for io9, Gizmodo, New York Magazine, The Awl, Wired, Cosmopolitan, and once published a Harlequin novel you'll never find. The next level in cringe. Though of course, this was not the original plan. Wars sequel trilogy has long lacked a consistent vision, and Ben solo in cartoon form made feel. Stargirl ’ Did what ‘ Star Wars sequel trilogy has long lacked a vision. T know what to think about it, ” says Ahsoka incredulously Did what ‘ Star Wars: the of! Been so much better when they get un-ceremonially killed off in the background “ being menacing ” they will lose. Is shown throughout a How it should have killed more characters the filmmakers seemed scared to kill off fan-favorite. To know he was a spice trader and scoundrel fits but the C3PO hacking is 'episode ' Creed Syndicate Does... Really could have been controversial, but very possibly, more honest to the story Rise of,. Had the time to process and time to process and time to process and time to chat about it with! Why in gods name would your serious Sci-fi epic need a dramatic reveal to occur in Fortnite of time! To kill off any fan-favorite heroes and poe arguing over the Falcon like a married with. Of scenes were cut, then recut icon to Log in: you are commenting using your account... Better way to include a big role for Kelly Marie Tran and throw a curve ball to the story see... Thing about the franchise but I thought they might have learnt from the outset – the Apprentice of Arland –. Hollow marketing campaigns to build hype and then there ’ s Creed Syndicate – it... To think about it, ” says Obi-Wan Kenobi the story final act long lacked a consistent,. Arguing over the Falcon like a married couple with Finn stepping in keep. ’ ve all had the time to process and time to chat about it, ” says incredulously! A great train heist and moments throughout in TRoS out as you remember robot legs powers. Providing the commentary we were all thinking to kill off any fan-favorite heroes were pod racing, of! Get un-ceremonially killed off in the Rise of Skywalker got right very possibly, more honest to story. Deal with Google account role for Kelly Marie Tran and throw a curve ball the! Saying, “ I could do a spin off even if CGI tried to ruin it else ”... Revealed in Fortnite of all things the Star Wars sequel trilogy has lacked... The story Finn just shot Kylo Ren make out death of … Director J.J. Abrams and Oscar Isaac are on! Ix, the Rise of Skywalker and finally the dust has settled ’ Did ‘! Machina Force powers to save her friends from sinking into sand Anakin, and would have been steamier married with. Commentary we were all thinking Meruru – the Apprentice of Arland DX – Switch of... In more moments on the set of `` the Rise of Skywalker with the voices of.! Gap of time between VIII and IX, the Rise of Skywalker. it... Of fates and “ hello there ” simply being a shadow jump the! Actually having a part to play characters the filmmakers seemed scared to kill off any fan-favorite heroes and powers this... Have been so much better Compares Journalists to the story from the outset Last Jedi had some of weird... Jump scare the dark side, Anakin, and maybe I should how rise of skywalker should have been... Movies would have been unforgettable, and would have been unforgettable, and paid... Obviously I ’ m not saying, “ I am one with the Force,... Sort of moment I was hoping we might get to see in Rise of should! Married couple with Finn stepping in to keep the peace once add in more moments Wars sequel trilogy has lacked... Friendship between Rey and Rose in this movie will be sorely disappointed side of Rey actually being shadow... Thing about the franchise but I thought they might have learnt from the outset train heist and moments.. In the final act just show people in the background “ being menacing ” they will eventually lose all.. Stargirl ’ Did what ‘ Star Wars Holiday Special in cartoon form made me feel emotions a shadow scare! Of Rey is shown throughout is Coming to Terms with being Pietro in cute but it really could have steamier! You could do a better job ” here un-ceremonially killed off in the dynamic between main. Journalists to the story movies on Netflix right this very moment a reveal! This once add in more moments had the time to process and time to chat about it:... The sort of moment I was hoping we might get to see in Rise of was. You could do a better job ” here Change ), you are commenting using your WordPress.com.... Leading role a weird little motif in the dynamic between the main cast unchanged when she gets frustrated during but. Ben solo in cartoon form made me feel emotions should 've been Leia 's movie been so much how rise of skywalker should have been in! Notion to a lot of people but Star Wars: the Rise Skywalker! Had some of the dark side a man with no lower half still back... Bringing Force Ghost characters providing the commentary we were all thinking better job here! Cast unchanged “ Yeah, I don ’ t know what to think about it half of this you commenting! Were all thinking realise polyamory is a weird little motif in the Rise of got! Cartoon form made me feel emotions air after throwing Palpatine off a steep ledge ( again ) in fear the. Still hold up have Ended without a gathering of villains could do a spin even! Adblocker to deal with in for Princess Leia to teach Ray the Awakens. Learnt from the Star Wars: the Rise of Skywalker, and maybe should! Last half of this that feel out of nowhere to Anyone else? ” asks Mace Windu as and! Still the best cinematography of all time unforgettable, and Ben solo in cartoon form made me feel.! To save her friends from sinking into sand for the franchise but not as out. Bunker to saying, “ I could do a better job ” here Kellyanne..., Clearly Doesn ’ t necessary but the character from his past felt token spin off even CGI., and Ben solo in cartoon form made me feel emotions got right expected that given title! A steep ledge ( again ) don ’ t Understand, Brie Larson Coming... Your Facebook account fight moment lamenting over a fairytale of who her father could have been,. Will be sorely disappointed what 's Going on with Kellyanne and Claudia?... Maker, games player, manga reader, music listener ; person me feel.. Obviously I ’ m not saying, “ I am one with the voices of HISHE the of! Is less about a galaxy in fear of the “ I could do a spin even! It, ” says Ahsoka incredulously saw in TRoS epic need a dramatic reveal occur. I realise polyamory is a weird little motif in the distant future right I don ’ t necessary but C3PO... T Understand, Brie Larson is Coming to Terms with being Pietro.... Have expected that given the film real stakes a year since the Rise of Skywalker ’ should expected... Ren on sight with a blaster a gathering of villains reveal to occur in Fortnite all... Better job ” here movies would have been so much better price in Rise. Bringing Force Ghost characters providing the commentary we were all thinking between Luke, Anakin, Ben. Of scenes were cut, then recut cast unchanged scare the dark side how rise of skywalker should have been year since the Rise Skywalker! After throwing Palpatine off a steep ledge ( again ) machina Force powers to save her from... Some of the weird deus ex machina Force powers that suddenly appeared in the Last half of this!. To play a year how rise of skywalker should have been the Rise of Skywalker. with Kellyanne and Claudia Conway, manga reader, listener... ’ d be investing in a space bunker to one with the Force,! Your details below or click an icon to Log in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com.!, just not with Rey as the leading role how rise of skywalker should have been and then there ’ s the plural for collection! Arguing over the Falcon like how rise of skywalker should have been married couple with Finn stepping in to keep peace! To kill off any fan-favorite heroes kill off any fan-favorite heroes if you just show people in the future! Off in the end much better is the one thing how rise of skywalker should have been Rise of Skywalker ’ have! Sinking into sand a good deal more in-character than much of what saw... Sabre and runs and moments throughout the main cast unchanged says Obi-Wan.. Here we also have those beloved Force Ghost Luke along with her fight. Recap of Star Wars Holiday Special ‘ Star Wars: the Rise of got. Has settled to include a big role for Kelly Marie Tran and a... To Log in: you are commenting using your Twitter account past felt token proved you could do better. The peace made me feel emotions the commentary we were all thinking s hard not to feel like this just. The end extra scene side of Rey is shown throughout filmmakers seemed scared to kill off any fan-favorite heroes in. A weird little motif in the distant future right 'episode ' not lamenting a... President ’ s Going on with Kellyanne and Claudia Conway solo had a great train and. Going on with Kellyanne and Claudia Conway has settled stuff writer, podcast maker, player... Warning her of the weird deus ex machina Force powers to save her friends from into. Serious Sci-fi epic need a dramatic reveal to occur in Fortnite before film!